When discussing a whip’s length, most whip crackers don’t measure their whip’s length in its entirety (i.e. from the beginning of the handle to the tip of the cracker). This is because whips are measured based on the part of the whip that is not easily replaceable; or, in other words, the part of the whip that can’t be removed/changed without having to take the whip apart. Typically, this means certain parts of the whip like the handle, fall, and cracker are not measured. For example:
Bullwhips are measured from the beginning of the handle to the end of the thong. This is because bullwhip handles are directly attached to the thong via the transition, and cannot be replaced without taking apart the entire whip. So, if you order a 5’ bullwhip, that means your whip will be 5’ long plus the length of the fall and the cracker. Therefore, a 5′ bullwhip may actually measure anywhere from 5.5′ to 7′ long.
Stockwhips are measured based only on the length of the thong. Because of the keeper knot, stockwhip handles can be easily replaced and are therefore not included in the measurement of the whip. So, if you order a 5’ stockwhip, your whip will be 5’ long plus the length of the handle and the length of the fall and cracker. Therefore, a 5′ stockwhip may actually measure anywhere from 7′ to 8.5′ long.
It is important to clarify whip length with your whip maker before ordering a whip in order to avoid confusion. Most whip makers are used to receiving questions from beginners, and would be happy to make you the whip you truly want.